Both look pretty good..
Ps Tapatalk works perfectly fine except for push updates. But I can live with that, as long as everything is all working for everyone else
Have a look at those skins as I think long term that's going to be the best option as it -
1) Doesn't need an additional application on your phone
2) It can differentiate between tables and mobile and only push to one or the other
3) Can prompt what we choose to either use that skin or the default one
4) We can control it
I am going to test it some more if you have any thoughts on that vs tapatalk I would be keen to hear it.